GST via ebay kicks in

Comments

• Rick Member Posts: 761 ✭✭✭ Daybiller

  July 1

  i complained to my local MP about how this affects collectors but got a pro forma letter in response, basically ignoring my concerns. 

  0 · Share on Facebook Share on Google+ Share on Twitter
• David Member Posts: 10,246 admin

  July 1

  Rick said:

  i complained to my local MP about how this affects collectors but got a pro forma letter in response, basically ignoring my concerns. 

  As a collector can also be a reseller ergo a dealer, how would you define who is who?
  

  David
  

  0 · Share on Facebook Share on Google+ Share on Twitter
• theartofmovieposters Member Posts: 4,032 ✭✭✭✭✭ Elite Collector

  July 2

  I would think a dealer is someone who's primary income comes from selling...someone who sells to fund their personal collection is a collector/hobbyist in my mind...

  0 · Share on Facebook Share on Google+ Share on Twitter
• Rick Member Posts: 761 ✭✭✭ Daybiller

  July 2

  I'm with Vesna

  0 · Share on Facebook Share on Google+ Share on Twitter
• theartofmovieposters Member Posts: 4,032 ✭✭✭✭✭ Elite Collector

  July 2

  And as previously agreed...Rick is a hoarder 

  0 · Share on Facebook Share on Google+ Share on Twitter
• David Member Posts: 10,246 admin

  July 2

  theartofmovieposters said:

  I would think a dealer is someone who's primary income comes from selling...someone who sells to fund their personal collection is a collector/hobbyist in my mind...

  On that basis I am not a dealer.
  
  The problem with GST is it is not a level playing field, if it is applied to all monetary transactions then it is fair for all. If you start picking and choosing then you end up with a Tampon tax.

  David
  

  0 · Share on Facebook Share on Google+ Share on Twitter
• theartofmovieposters Member Posts: 4,032 ✭✭✭✭✭ Elite Collector

  July 2

  David said:

  theartofmovieposters said:

  I would think a dealer is someone who's primary income comes from selling...someone who sells to fund their personal collection is a collector/hobbyist in my mind...

  On that basis I am not a dealer.
  
  The problem with GST is it is not a level playing field, if it is applied to all monetary transactions then it is fair for all. If you start picking and choosing then you end up with a Tampon tax.

  Don't get me started....

  0 · Share on Facebook Share on Google+ Share on Twitter
• David Member Posts: 10,246 admin

  July 2

  Yup...real stupid.
  
  So Rick wants collectors exempt from paying GST, then it's probably fair that people who buy medical supplies and health supplements on eBay should be exempt, because it is not for fun it is for health and healthy is good for society...and so on.
  
  Besides, how many times does a "collector" swoop in on an unsuspecting seller who has listed an item not knowing what it is worth and then that "collector" buys it and simply flips it for profit...that is a business. I am not criticising the buyer for doing that, but 9 times out of 10 the purchase is made with the sole intent of making a quick buck not some altruistic notion that they will be able to afford the Pretty Woman 1SH they've had their eye on for a while...
  
  It's too hard to pick and choose who to exempt and who to not, because as sure as eggs don't bounce someone will find a way to exploit the exemption and then how is it fair?
  

  David
  

  0 · Share on Facebook Share on Google+ Share on Twitter